CO129-099 - Sir Robinson - 1864 [6-8] — Page 344

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

77

340

which I sent to him on the subject. In an unofficial note transmitting these answers he observes: -

"As regards query No 3, I may cite in instance the case of the bad one Panama - a very bad and murderous case of piracy. The examination of the twenty-four prisoners taken extended over a period of two months. The depositions furnished have been told pirates that you decapitated in remark are not every case but only in very bad ones, such being the fact.

Trials in criminal cases are generally conducted fairly enough. Of course they understand their own people and have means of obtaining their previous history and occupations. The proceedings which were full and voluminous, extended over a period of above two months, the result being that sixteen of these men were beheaded and eight flogged and banished.

I thought all were certain of decapitation, but extenuating circumstances were admitted in favour of eight of them, bringing home proof that our courts would not admit, at least it would be controverted by those learned in the law whose duty it is to pull their clients through at all risks. I believe your references to the Secretary of State that if the project is carried out with care it will do an immense deal of good."

Edit History

2026-05-19 06:57:37 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
77 340 which I sent to him on the subject. In an unofficial note transmitting these answers he observes: - "As regards query No 3, I may cite in instance the case of the bad one Panama - a very bad and murderous case of piracy. The examination of the twenty-four prisoners taken extended over a period of two months. The depositions furnished have been told pirates that you decapitated in remark are not every case but only in very bad ones, such being the fact. Trials in criminal cases are generally conducted fairly enough. Of course they understand their own people and have means of obtaining their previous history and occupations. The proceedings which were full and voluminous, extended over a period of above two months, the result being that sixteen of these men were beheaded and eight flogged and banished. I thought all were certain of decapitation, but extenuating circumstances were admitted in favour of eight of them, bringing home proof that our courts would not admit, at least it would be controverted by those learned in the law whose duty it is to pull their clients through at all risks. I believe your references to the Secretary of State that if the project is carried out with care it will do an immense deal of good."
Baseline (Original)
16. 77 340 which I fint to him on the subject. In aw unofficial note transmitting thiso answers he observes: - "as regards query No 3 may Cite in instance the case of the bad one Panama - a very and nurdu. of piracy The examination of the twentir for prisoners taken - months. The depositions furnished "I mention this in proof of your have been told pirates that you decapitated in remark are not every case but only in very bad ones such being the # fact. · generally Trials in criminal cases are Conducted fairly enough. Of course they understand their own people and have means of obtaining their previous history ations which and occupations Extended over a · furiod of above two of m for my pervoal were full and voluminous, the result being that Siseteen of these men were beheaded and Eight flogged and banished. I thought all were certain of ~ decapitation, but externating circumstances were admitted for right of for Eight of them. bringo home.. proof that om courts would not admit at least it would be upset Controverted by thou learned in the law whose duty it is to their clients to pull them through at all risks. I believe Your references to the Secretary of State if the project is carried out with work an immense deal of Good."
2026-05-19 06:57:37 · Baseline
View content

16.

77

340

which I fint to him on the subject. In

aw

unofficial note transmitting thiso

answers he observes: -

"as

regards query

No 3

may

Cite in instance the case

of

the

bad

one

Panama - a very

and nurdu.

of piracy

The examination of

the twentir for prisoners taken -

months. The depositions furnished

"I mention this in proof of your

have been told pirates

that

you decapitated in

remark

are not

every

case but only in very

bad ones such being the

#

fact.

· generally

Trials in criminal cases are

Conducted

fairly enough. Of course they

understand their

own

people and have

means of obtaining their previous history

ations which

and occupations

Extended over

a

· furiod of above two

of

m

for my pervoal

were

full and

voluminous, the result being that Siseteen of these men were beheaded

and Eight flogged

and banished.

I thought all were certain of ~ decapitation, but externating circumstances

were

admitted for right of

for Eight of them.

bringo

home..

proof that om courts would not admit

at least it would be

upset

Controverted by thou learned in the law whose duty it is to their clients to pull them through at all risks. I believe Your references to the Secretary of State if the project is carried out with work an immense deal of Good."

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.